http://www.damongudaitis.com/analytics/serp-report-google-analytics.html

There are a number of good reasons for your result.

1. My filters combine Google, Yahoo, and MSN/Live into one report.

If you want to separate the results, then create separate profiles for each of Google, Yahoo, and MSN rankings.

Then instead of the Search Engine Visitors filter, create 3 filters using google\.[a-z]+ for Google, yahoo\.[a-z]+ for Yahoo, and (live|msn)\.[a-z]+ for MSN as your filter pattern for each profile.

All the other filters can remain the same.

2. Local search results. Search results change based on the location of the searcher. Even if you do the above filter, you should expect to see some discrepencies.

thank you for the fine specifications. i have implemented them and i get results.
i have though one interesting result:
– the filter says that one of the keywords are shown both on the first and on the second page. when i google that keyword it appears on the second page.

i would like to understand why is that, and how could i have a real report.

thank you
robert.

Presuming you used the same names for the filters as I detailed in my original, and now updated, post on clean ranking report, make the following changes:

Search Ranking Filter
-Change Field A->Extract A fromReferral to Campaign Term
-Change Field A->Extract A from (\?|&)(q|p)=([^&]*) to (.*)
-Change Output To->Constructor from $A3 (page: $B3) to $A1 | page: $B3

Page 1 Filter
-Change Search String from \(page: \) to page:$
-Change Replace String from \(page: 1\) to page: 1

Page 2+ Filters
-Change Search String from page 1([0-1])\) to page: 1[0-1]$
-Change Replace String from page 2\) to page: 2

Of course you will need to increment the first number in both the search and replace strings for the subsequent pages .